Related:
“A new study by Western University in Ontario says that if you’ve got a car with a modified exhaust system, odds are you’re a guy and probably also psychotic and sadistic.”
The study is being filtered through a blog post (which isn’t even accurate enough to get the source of the paper correct, attributing it to “Western University in Ontario”).
The study itself is written by one author and published in a journal by the University of Gdańsk of little import. That’s, of course, just an indicator it might not be the most credible.
I will defend psychology as a science until I’m blue in the face, but it is right now undergoing a serious replication crisis, especially because of its poorly representative sampling.
The sample is: “A sample of 529 (52% men) undergraduate business students”, which is a laughably biased sample compared to a global population. They never say which university, but given the publication and the author’s workplace, it’s safe to revise that to “529 (52% men) undergraduate business students at U. Gdańsk”.
As the author notes, the mean score from the three questions pertaining to “I want to fuck my car” wasn’t all that high (approximate average of “somewhat disagree” on all three with approximate standard deviation of a single “neither agree nor disagree”). This means the actual sample of people who had the problem being addressed in the title of the study was vanishingly small.
This, to me, is flimsy evidence at best even when I already buy into the basic premise.
Related: “A new study by Western University in Ontario says that if you’ve got a car with a modified exhaust system, odds are you’re a guy and probably also psychotic and sadistic.”
https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a60983144/study-loud-exhaust-psychotic/
A few (major) caveats:
This, to me, is flimsy evidence at best even when I already buy into the basic premise.
Thank you for this! I was not familiar with all these shortcomings when I shared that study. I will not share it in the future.
Not true. I don’t have a modified exhaust system.
this whole post should be in fuck_motorbikes