There’s a major problem here, and it’s that you don’t seem to understand the Marxist-Leninist views on China, Russia, and the DPRK, or what Marxist-Leninists believe socialism is.
Russia is not a socialist country, correct. It’s a capitalist country run by nationalists. MLs do not support Russia, they critically support it, meaning MLs strategically align with Russia against the US Empire while disapproving of their socioeconomic system. It’s similar to why MLs critically support Iran and Palestine, despite neither being socialist movements.
China is a socialist country. It has hierarchy, correct, but that’s not a problem for Marxists. What’s important for Marxists is that the working class is in control of the state, and that social ownership is the principal, ie rising and dominant, aspect of the economy. Marxism is not a dogma that says everything should be totally equal immediately, instead we believe the economic basis of communism requires highly developed, centralized industry, and so China publicly owns the commanding heights of the economy while marketizing developing sectors. This is classical Marxism. The DPRK has an alternate, more siege socialist mode of production, but maintains working class control of the state and social ownership as principal.
Next, socialism in general. Welfare is not socialism. Public ownership is not socialism by itself, either. Norway has capitalists in charge of the state, and private ownership as the principal aspect of its economy. Welfare under capitalism isn’t socialism, just like private ownership under socialism is not capitalism.
Overall, I think you should talk to us MLs about what our beliefs actually are, rather than just assuming you know better than us about what we believe.
Do tell me in what way the farmers and industry workers have any control of literally anything in North Korea?
And how can you say welfare isn’t socialism? Much of the point is to provide a safety net so none of your country men become destitute. Oligarchy is what marxism was meant to stop, and yet it is maintained in both countries. North Korea doesn’t even bother to hide that it is a straight up dictatorship other than adding; Democrat, peoples, and Republic to their name. None of which actually represents reality.
Look at the difference between Norway’s prisons and those of those other 3 countries. That alone should tell you who the good guys and bad guys are. They try to help people as opposed to punishing them. That raises the quality of life for all individuals in the country. Hiding them away in a prison for talking about ideas? That’s not socialism in any way, shape or form and all three of those countries do that.
Maybe you should talk to more MLs with a stance that you’re coming with an open but more skeptical mind. Erase what you thought you knew about socialism, and really pay attention to what they say. They’ll use circular logic, non sequiturs, and hasty generalizations. In fact you, yourself used the fallacy of appealing to popularity. If your argument doesn’t stand up here, then I should go where all the MLs go so they can gang up on me. Your argument should be strong enough to stand up anywhere, especially somewhere with as many socialists as Lemmy has.
Do tell me in what way the farmers and industry workers have any control of literally anything in North Korea?
Nearly all land, industry, and agriculture is socially-owned. Through systems like Taean workers democratically control their workplaces, in what is described as the Mass Line applied to the factory level. There are close to no capitalists outside of special regions like the Rason Special Economic Zone, which mostly exists for trade with Russia and China.
And how can you say welfare isn’t socialism? Much of the point is to provide a safety net so none of your country men become destitute.
Welfare is an important part of socialism, but it isn’t socialism itself. Socialism is a mode of production and distribution where the working classes control the state, and social ownership is the principal aspect of the economy. This essentially translates to a pro-worker system, which better enables welfare.
Oligarchy is what marxism was meant to stop, and yet it is maintained in both countries. North Korea doesn’t even bother to hide that it is a straight up dictatorship other than adding; Democrat, peoples, and Republic to their name. None of which actually represents reality.
It’s pretty clear that you’ve done no research whatsoever on how the DPRK functions, or how they describe themselves. They do not consider themselves a dictatorship, nor are they controlled by an “oligarchy.” The democratic process in the DPRK is based on approval voting, where consensus is built on what candidate should be voted on, and then in the second round people vote yes or no. In some regions, as of a couple years ago, they have begun rolling out western-style primary elections before the second approval round. I recommend reading professor Roland Boer’s Socialism in Power: On the Theory and History of Socialist Governance for more, though it’s a tad outdated since it was published in 2023.
Look at the difference between Norway’s prisons and those of those other 3 countries. That alone should tell you who the good guys and bad guys are.
I’m a Marxist, I don’t see the world in Marvel-style “good vs. evil.” Norway is an imperialist country that funds its welfare from unequal exchange and plundering the global south, simple as that. Norway is an enemy of the global working class until it has a socialist revolution.
They try to help people as opposed to punishing them. That raises the quality of life for all individuals in the country. Hiding them away in a prison for talking about ideas? That’s not socialism in any way, shape or form and all three of those countries do that.
How do you think socialist prisons function? Where did you get this information from? Further, Russia is a capitalist country just like Norway, I don’t defend its systems in any way.
Maybe you should talk to more MLs with a stance that you’re coming with an open but more skeptical mind. Erase what you thought you knew about socialism, and really pay attention to what they say. They’ll use circular logic, non sequiturs, and hasty generalizations. In fact you, yourself used the fallacy of appealing to popularity. If your argument doesn’t stand up here, then I should go where all the MLs go so they can gang up on me. Your argument should be strong enough to stand up anywhere, especially somewhere with as many socialists as Lemmy has.
I’m a Marxist-Leninist myself, I’m thoroughly enmeshed within Marxism-Leninism. I’ve made arguments for Marxism-Leninism in many places on Lemmy and held my own. I read Marx, Engels, Lenin, and many more Marxist and Marxist-Leninist writers. I have yet to see an actual point made by you backed in either a source or in Marxist-Leninist theory. I think you should try to be a bit more open-minded and pay a bit more attention, because you seem confused on both what Marxism-Leninism is and what Marxist-Leninists believe.
Ad hominem, false dichotomy, circular argument. Not to mention straight lies, but ok, you sure “hold your own” in arguments. I’m done with this conversation.
No? Nothing I said was a lie, I backed up every claim I made, and carried a coherent argument. Flipping the chess board over because you found yourself out of your depth isn’t a winning move, either admit you didn’t know as much as you thought you did or return with something proving your points against mine.
There’s a major problem here, and it’s that you don’t seem to understand the Marxist-Leninist views on China, Russia, and the DPRK, or what Marxist-Leninists believe socialism is.
Russia is not a socialist country, correct. It’s a capitalist country run by nationalists. MLs do not support Russia, they critically support it, meaning MLs strategically align with Russia against the US Empire while disapproving of their socioeconomic system. It’s similar to why MLs critically support Iran and Palestine, despite neither being socialist movements.
China is a socialist country. It has hierarchy, correct, but that’s not a problem for Marxists. What’s important for Marxists is that the working class is in control of the state, and that social ownership is the principal, ie rising and dominant, aspect of the economy. Marxism is not a dogma that says everything should be totally equal immediately, instead we believe the economic basis of communism requires highly developed, centralized industry, and so China publicly owns the commanding heights of the economy while marketizing developing sectors. This is classical Marxism. The DPRK has an alternate, more siege socialist mode of production, but maintains working class control of the state and social ownership as principal.
Next, socialism in general. Welfare is not socialism. Public ownership is not socialism by itself, either. Norway has capitalists in charge of the state, and private ownership as the principal aspect of its economy. Welfare under capitalism isn’t socialism, just like private ownership under socialism is not capitalism.
Overall, I think you should talk to us MLs about what our beliefs actually are, rather than just assuming you know better than us about what we believe.
Do tell me in what way the farmers and industry workers have any control of literally anything in North Korea?
And how can you say welfare isn’t socialism? Much of the point is to provide a safety net so none of your country men become destitute. Oligarchy is what marxism was meant to stop, and yet it is maintained in both countries. North Korea doesn’t even bother to hide that it is a straight up dictatorship other than adding; Democrat, peoples, and Republic to their name. None of which actually represents reality.
Look at the difference between Norway’s prisons and those of those other 3 countries. That alone should tell you who the good guys and bad guys are. They try to help people as opposed to punishing them. That raises the quality of life for all individuals in the country. Hiding them away in a prison for talking about ideas? That’s not socialism in any way, shape or form and all three of those countries do that.
Maybe you should talk to more MLs with a stance that you’re coming with an open but more skeptical mind. Erase what you thought you knew about socialism, and really pay attention to what they say. They’ll use circular logic, non sequiturs, and hasty generalizations. In fact you, yourself used the fallacy of appealing to popularity. If your argument doesn’t stand up here, then I should go where all the MLs go so they can gang up on me. Your argument should be strong enough to stand up anywhere, especially somewhere with as many socialists as Lemmy has.
Nearly all land, industry, and agriculture is socially-owned. Through systems like Taean workers democratically control their workplaces, in what is described as the Mass Line applied to the factory level. There are close to no capitalists outside of special regions like the Rason Special Economic Zone, which mostly exists for trade with Russia and China.
Welfare is an important part of socialism, but it isn’t socialism itself. Socialism is a mode of production and distribution where the working classes control the state, and social ownership is the principal aspect of the economy. This essentially translates to a pro-worker system, which better enables welfare.
It’s pretty clear that you’ve done no research whatsoever on how the DPRK functions, or how they describe themselves. They do not consider themselves a dictatorship, nor are they controlled by an “oligarchy.” The democratic process in the DPRK is based on approval voting, where consensus is built on what candidate should be voted on, and then in the second round people vote yes or no. In some regions, as of a couple years ago, they have begun rolling out western-style primary elections before the second approval round. I recommend reading professor Roland Boer’s Socialism in Power: On the Theory and History of Socialist Governance for more, though it’s a tad outdated since it was published in 2023.
I’m a Marxist, I don’t see the world in Marvel-style “good vs. evil.” Norway is an imperialist country that funds its welfare from unequal exchange and plundering the global south, simple as that. Norway is an enemy of the global working class until it has a socialist revolution.
How do you think socialist prisons function? Where did you get this information from? Further, Russia is a capitalist country just like Norway, I don’t defend its systems in any way.
I’m a Marxist-Leninist myself, I’m thoroughly enmeshed within Marxism-Leninism. I’ve made arguments for Marxism-Leninism in many places on Lemmy and held my own. I read Marx, Engels, Lenin, and many more Marxist and Marxist-Leninist writers. I have yet to see an actual point made by you backed in either a source or in Marxist-Leninist theory. I think you should try to be a bit more open-minded and pay a bit more attention, because you seem confused on both what Marxism-Leninism is and what Marxist-Leninists believe.
Ad hominem, false dichotomy, circular argument. Not to mention straight lies, but ok, you sure “hold your own” in arguments. I’m done with this conversation.
No? Nothing I said was a lie, I backed up every claim I made, and carried a coherent argument. Flipping the chess board over because you found yourself out of your depth isn’t a winning move, either admit you didn’t know as much as you thought you did or return with something proving your points against mine.