I am live.

  • 0 Posts
  • 774 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 7th, 2023

help-circle

  • I mean, that’s certainly your interpretation. An incorrect one, in my opinion, but nevertheless, you’re entitled to it.

    More importantly, it’s completely beside the point of what I was trying to communicate and has very little relevance to the actual discussion.

    It doesn’t matter who creates the media, so long as the result is novel. If I ask an LLM to generate an image of a flower, and that image has never existed before, then it is, by definition, something new. You are perfectly entitled to refuse to call it art. That’s your prerogative. But beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and art is ultimately a subjective designation. I can call something art just as easily as you can refuse to.

    And, unfortunately, for both of us, what either of us personally considers art has absolutely no bearing on the novelty, existence, or validity of the resulting creation. Our personal opinions on the matter are entirely irrelevant to those questions.








  • Let’s assume, for a moment, that LLMs are trained on publicly available data. In other words, they’re not stealing or pirating that data, just to simplify the argument. (Although, to be fair, some LLM developers have done exactly that and are facing legal consequences.)

    Publicly available data is just that: publicly available. Anyone can access it, including individuals, businesses, and AI developers. They’re not stealing something that is freely accessible to literally everyone.

    And that’s the dilemma: either that information is freely available to everyone, or it isn’t. You can’t argue that it’s free for you and me to access but somehow off-limits to OpenAI or Grok simply because they’re using it for a different purpose. That’s not how public access works.

    So, they’re not stealing anything under the assumption we’re making here. To answer your original question, no, I don’t have an issue with them stealing the internet.






  • I will admit that it is possible I need to make my position a little clearer. The vast majority of comments on this platform are overwhelmingly critical of AI in other posts, yet many of those same people were praising it when it was being used to decompile video games and jailbreak the PS5.

    I am simply, once again, pointing out the two-faced nature of this platform. My gripe, if you will, is consistency. If you hate AI, then hate it for everything it does, including the things that might actually be beneficial. It’s convenient to play both sides and act as a devil’s advocate when it suits your position, but ultimately, that’s a useless and self-defeating stance.

    If you’re going to take a centrist position on AI, then do that. Praise it where it deserves praise and criticize it where it deserves criticism. But don’t turn around and say you hate everything about AI in one breath, only to make an exception when it happens to serve your interests.


  • Your first comment, accusing me of treating the comment section as one unified opinion, is a straw man. It is significantly easier to defend an argument when you change it entirely, rather than address what I actually said. I was arguably addressing the comment section as a collective, not suggesting that every individual held the exact same opinion. Your response demonstrates that you either misunderstand or are misusing the term logical fallacy.

    Your second statement is pure nonsense for the same reason. You clearly don’t understand what a false dichotomy is. I didn’t introduce a dichotomy or present two mutually exclusive positions. I simply asked a question: which is it?

    Please stop throwing around logical fallacies when you don’t understand what they mean. It derails the conversation entirely. Instead of addressing the substance of my argument, you’ve changed the discussion into an argument about whether I understand logical fallacies. Worse, you’ve completely avoided addressing the actual point I was making. That’s precisely the kind of diversion that prevents any meaningful discussion.



  • Yet another absolutely fascinating comment section. Let me try to understand what is happening here.

    Are some of you upset because Claude can no longer do this? Were you perfectly happy with AI being used to decompile games and circumvent Sony’s PlayStation ecosystem when it was being used to stick it to a major corporation? But now that Anthropic has decided to prohibit this particular use of its technology, suddenly AI is terrible again? Suddenly it devalues human labor, which, incidentally, isn’t really what is happening here. In many instances, it eliminates the need for that labor altogether.

    Then there are those arguing that only AI companies should be allowed to do these things, rather than independent individuals. Which is, quite frankly, a ridiculous argument. Companies have every right to dictate how their products and services are used, particularly when we’re talking about a proprietary service like Claude. You don’t own Claude. You don’t purchase the underlying technology. It belongs to Anthropic, and Anthropic gets to establish the terms under which it is made available.

    So which is it? Do you oppose AI on principle, or do you only oppose it when it doesn’t serve your particular interests? Is AI the enemy of human creativity and labor, except when it’s being used to accomplish something you personally want?

    I’d appreciate a little consistency from this user base. Surely that’s not too much to ask.


  • What exactly are you suggesting here? That using an LLM to reverse-engineer a video game, modify its code, and create an entirely new experience constitutes plagiarism?

    Do you understand what plagiarism actually means? It means passing off someone else’s work as your own. It has absolutely nothing to do with whether someone uses AI to reverse-engineer software, modify an existing game, or develop an entirely new way to experience it.

    There may be legitimate arguments to be made about copyright infringement and intellectual property rights, but those are entirely different discussions.

    And what does the statement about AI companies being the only ones allowed to plagiarize even mean? Are you suggesting that modifying an existing video game is somehow equivalent to an AI company training a model on copyrighted material?

    You’re conflating completely different concepts, and the result is an accusation that doesn’t even make sense in the context of what’s being discussed.


  • And that would only exemplify my point.

    The voting systems on platforms like this are based almost exclusively on the honor system, even more so on Lemmy, where votes aren’t calculated and tallied in the same manner as they are on Reddit. Ultimately, they serve little purpose beyond providing a metric for measuring how much engagement a post is receiving.

    Technically, according to the platform’s own rules, you’re supposed to vote on the content and context of a post, not your knee-jerk emotional reaction to it. Whether or not you like me, my tone, or the way I express myself should have absolutely no bearing on how you evaluate the factual merit of my comment.

    For the record, I’m fully aware of this phenomenon, and I’m perfectly prepared to receive whatever negative attention comes with it. However, sometimes calling people out for what they are isn’t necessarily being mean. Sometimes it’s simply being brutally honest.

    The complete lack of even a basic understanding of how the American stock market works is genuinely shocking. These are people with access to the internet, meaning they have the resources to educate themselves, yet they choose instead to broadcast their uninformed opinions for everyone else to shake their heads at.

    There is absolutely no accountability here. Nobody, least of all the administrators, seems particularly interested in holding anyone responsible for the misinformation and intellectual sewage being presented as legitimate information.

    And that’s why you think I’m being mean. I’m not. I’m simply unwilling to pretend that ignorance is knowledge or that uninformed opinions deserve the same consideration as factual, well-reasoned arguments.