I practice RA and I’d advocate for every human on earth to do the same. BUT I also believe that a lot of us are genuinely built for monogamy, myself included. My biggest problem with RA is that practitioners have a tendency to devalue relationship structures that resemble anything pre-RA.
What counts as cheating is entirely up to the individuals in the relationship. RA doesn’t prescribe any set views on it. It’s not a poly thing or a mono thing. RA is about intentional choice.
Sorry to disagree, but while cheating is frowned upon in ENM and is explecitly stated that it contradicts the E in ENM (unless the partners agree to it, in which case it is not cheating), RA does not see cheating as a bad thing at all, as the consent of third parties not involved in the act is irrelevant. And lots of RA literature encourages it.
This is wild I have no idea what ENM or RA is but what it really sounds like is a bunch of men trying to justify their egregiously shitty behavior in relationships.
All RA literature I found is inherently written though a feminist lens and/or queer lens. and from what I’ve seen around, mostly written by queer women (although most of it is usually anonymised).
Those men you’re talking about? I doubt they read queer anarchist literature,
I guess men don’t have a monopoly on rationalizing their shitty behaviour in relationships? Lol
I mean if I like hitting women I know there are women out there that like being hit. Does that mean I just need to find the right woman for me that likes being hit and that makes it acceptable? Two consenting adults after all.
Yes I know I’m exaggerating, no I know it’s not the same thing but at the same time… Kinda what it is.
I’m having a hard time wrapping my head around this. To me, “cheating” is a form of dishonesty. If you are in a relationship that is sexually/romantically nonexclusive, then “cheating” doesn’t exist, since there is a mutual understanding of nonexclusivity. I don’t see how ‘anarchy’ would justify dishonesty within an intimate relationship.
the concept is that under no relationship, any party gets to veto things that don’t affect them.
i can’t tell my partner that she isn’t allowed to stuff with someone else, all the consent that counts is from the people involved in the act.
but more importantly, it acknowledges that some people are stuck in abusive relationships and if they find an ounce of affection outside their hell, then that’s a good thing.
I’m trying to understand. I certainly understand the point of view that intimacy needn’t be exclusive. What I’m not clear is whether that point of view need be shared by both parties in one of these relationships. Let’s leave aside the question of abusive relationships for the moment.
the point is that one person not liking the idea, shouldn’t interfere with the other one’s agency, they are free to disagree, they are not free to impose their rules.
I don’t know if this is just semantics or what, but isn’t that almost every relationship already? Like do whatever you want, but don’t expect the other person to necessarily like it.
The cool thing about anarchy is that nobody is in charge. Others may see it differently than I do, but there is no authority to say which interpretation is correct or incorrect.
exactly, you can’t tell your partner that because she has a relationship with you, she isn’t allowed to do what she wants with other people. you’re allowed not to have a relationship with get, but you can put rules on other people.
I practice RA and I’d advocate for every human on earth to do the same. BUT I also believe that a lot of us are genuinely built for monogamy, myself included. My biggest problem with RA is that practitioners have a tendency to devalue relationship structures that resemble anything pre-RA.
it’s the only one that thinks cheating isn’t a big deal. that’s the controversial part
What counts as cheating is entirely up to the individuals in the relationship. RA doesn’t prescribe any set views on it. It’s not a poly thing or a mono thing. RA is about intentional choice.
Sorry to disagree, but while cheating is frowned upon in ENM and is explecitly stated that it contradicts the E in ENM (unless the partners agree to it, in which case it is not cheating), RA does not see cheating as a bad thing at all, as the consent of third parties not involved in the act is irrelevant. And lots of RA literature encourages it.
This is wild I have no idea what ENM or RA is but what it really sounds like is a bunch of men trying to justify their egregiously shitty behavior in relationships.
All RA literature I found is inherently written though a feminist lens and/or queer lens. and from what I’ve seen around, mostly written by queer women (although most of it is usually anonymised).
Those men you’re talking about? I doubt they read queer anarchist literature,
I guess men don’t have a monopoly on rationalizing their shitty behaviour in relationships? Lol
I mean if I like hitting women I know there are women out there that like being hit. Does that mean I just need to find the right woman for me that likes being hit and that makes it acceptable? Two consenting adults after all.
Yes I know I’m exaggerating, no I know it’s not the same thing but at the same time… Kinda what it is.
“Queer women say people should not demand who their partner is allowed to see or be with”
Chud online
“Then why can’t I hit women? checkmate”
I’m having a hard time wrapping my head around this. To me, “cheating” is a form of dishonesty. If you are in a relationship that is sexually/romantically nonexclusive, then “cheating” doesn’t exist, since there is a mutual understanding of nonexclusivity. I don’t see how ‘anarchy’ would justify dishonesty within an intimate relationship.
the concept is that under no relationship, any party gets to veto things that don’t affect them.
i can’t tell my partner that she isn’t allowed to stuff with someone else, all the consent that counts is from the people involved in the act.
but more importantly, it acknowledges that some people are stuck in abusive relationships and if they find an ounce of affection outside their hell, then that’s a good thing.
I’m trying to understand. I certainly understand the point of view that intimacy needn’t be exclusive. What I’m not clear is whether that point of view need be shared by both parties in one of these relationships. Let’s leave aside the question of abusive relationships for the moment.
the point is that one person not liking the idea, shouldn’t interfere with the other one’s agency, they are free to disagree, they are not free to impose their rules.
I don’t know if this is just semantics or what, but isn’t that almost every relationship already? Like do whatever you want, but don’t expect the other person to necessarily like it.
The cool thing about anarchy is that nobody is in charge. Others may see it differently than I do, but there is no authority to say which interpretation is correct or incorrect.
exactly, you can’t tell your partner that because she has a relationship with you, she isn’t allowed to do what she wants with other people. you’re allowed not to have a relationship with get, but you can put rules on other people.