• Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    19 hours ago

    Romania is a mixed-bag, it was better earlier on but as I understand in the 80s it was rough due to austerity measures by Ceaușescu to pay back IMF loans. Of course I have a different interpretation of Kronstadt than Goldman, I’m a Marxist, not an anarchist, and moreover Kronstadt was spearheaded by a White Army sympathizer anyways. Not really sure what you’re getting at specifically here.

    • lugal@sopuli.xyz
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      19 hours ago

      Well, she moved to Western Germany in the 70s. And people from the GDR don’t have only good things to say about it either. It’s not only western propaganda but lived experience. Many didn’t want the reunification but they wanted a democratic GDR because it wasn’t.

      And Kronstadt were when The Party centralized its power away from the soviets (as in councils). But sure, it was the evil Whites.

      • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        18 hours ago

        Anecdote and personal account obviously varies.

        As for Kronstadt, soviet power was solidified. The mutineers wanted preferential treatment and an end to Bolshevik soviets, against the will of the majority of workers and peasants. Their demands were suicidal for the Red Army against the Whites, and Stepan Petrichenko fled to join the Whites shortly after.

        • lugal@sopuli.xyz
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          3 hours ago

          Anecdote and personal account obviously varies.

          So you at least kind of acknowledge that it’s not only capitalist propaganda as you usually insist but it includes people who lived there, including socialists, including anarchists (and also left Marxists btw). That’s at least something.

          Btw, I love how you refer to “Bolshevik soviets” after I made the distinction between Bolsheviks and soviets but what was I expecting.

          • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            3 hours ago

            Of course individuals have their own opinions on matters that form a massive mosaic of overall views, but the overall support was in favor of the Bolsheviks. The Kronstadt mutiny wanted to make the Bolsheviks impossible to vote for in the Soviets, so they wanted an anti-democratic imposition of their will on the rest of the soviets. Further, just as other factions opposed the Marxists, many anarchists and “left”-Marxists joined the Red Army and supported the Bolsheviks. It wasn’t a binary affair, the rejection of the Bolsheviks by some non-Marxists existed alongside the embrace of the Bolsheviks by many non-Marxists.

            In short, the people coalesced around and supported the Bolsheviks, not the mutineers, and what the mutineers wanted would have been disastrous and anti-democratic. The leader of the mutiny, Stepan Petrichenko, joined the White Army after Kronstadt. This isn’t the decisive battle between evil Marxists and good anarchists, it was a battle between the majority of society and a small group of wreckers that quickly overthrew their own leadership and returned to the Red Army.

            Most important of all, though, is that this has nothing to do with the initial question: what anarchist critique of Marxism holds up well? Not whenever the two groups may have fought, I mean specific critique of Marxism itself.