This is a broad question meant to cover multiple pathways as to what is considered mainstream media. They can be character representatives, ongoing series or what have you.
I’m going to elect to focus on the general sense of the appeal of mainstream media. To me, mainstream media is a manufactured construct that is built to market. It is plastic, it plays safe, it relies on predictability, it re-runs the same formula, it never challenges itself .etc And nothing really remains as a point of some permanent progress, if but only temporarily before falling back to status quo.
It’s vanilla as vanilla can be, which is okay in doses, but not okay in large quantities. And to help clarify some things too, is that I’m not focused on news organizations because there are entertainment venues as well to consider. I know a lot of people will immediately think of some news broadcasting station they don’t like because of the filtered malformed information projected to push agendas or appease certain demographics to influence votes or opinions on a wide scale.
I’m just interested to see what people come up in their own words about what thing from mainstream media that they don’t like about it.
I agree that there isn’t a firm definition of “mainstream” or even “popular”. I think it’s fair to say that my tastes are all over the map, with some media I would call mainstream and much that I wouldn’t.
In the end, I think it comes down to a matter of taste. I like stories that are intellectually engaging with characters that have a strong arc and maintain their character integrity1 over the course of the story. A close second are productions that are an audio/visual feast for the senses, and a third, stories that make me think or try to guess what comes next. Educational media is also a preference, but it still needs good production and narration. Music is mostly the same affair, without the heavy focus on character drama of course. Games slot into the same psychological go-zones.
This means that things like “reality TV” and recap-heavy shows, just don’t cut it. I never liked The Real World when it first aired, and the format has only found ways to get worse from there. A huge swath of podcasts, reaction content, and “critical” commentary online also falls into the same low-effort-media trap - I have to listen at 200% speed just to jog past all the fluff and get to the content. We did all this back in the day with AM radio, and I wasn’t listening then, either.
As for trendy TikTok style videos, they have their place but it’s not for me. People are gonna meme and build parasocial communities around broadcasting and consuming content. I find myself watching short-form youtube videos here and there, but usually as a pit-stop on the way to do something more interesting. It’s never been an objective unto itself.
Overall, I like stimulating media. If your show or movie expects me to have my attention divided to my phone, is poorly written, or is just slapped together, I’m going to play a game or read a book instead. I really do crave having my whole cortex lit up like a x-mas tree, and I simply don’t have the time for anything less.
Edit: I’ll add that aggressively ad-blocking everything on every device I own has been a godsend for my sanity. Consuming media is a night-and-day different experience this way, as it’s just better for your psyche. It’s at the point now where being exposed to someone else’s TV or using someone else’s device is like traveling to a different country.
- A lot of horror stories depend on one or more characters suddenly doing something stupid, in a way that is just wildly out of check with the personality the story set up thus far. At times it’s practically action without motiviation - just robotic nonsense to move the plot forward. It’s not hard to build in a character flaw that makes sense, but often even that low bar just isn’t cleared. In fact, such characters are often more interesting so there’s no reason not to.
Notice mainstream podcasts are all garbage in any language. They all follow formats and themes of How to Be Healthy (Thin) or How to Be Successful (Rich), or the other enorous genres are True Crime and “pretend you have three friends that must be funny because that one person is constantly laughing.”
Basically, any top 50 podcast is gonna be garbage.
Nothing. The competition is some random asshole’s influencer channel. That’s worse.
Oh, not just news. Well, there too, some low-budget indie thing could be good, or it could be terrible, formulaic slop. Those network cop shows for old people suck, but if you cast even a bit of a wider net, there’s quality, challenging, thought-provoking content to be had.
The stupid insistence on “objectivity”. Being objective is impossible, saying your reporters are is no different from claiming they’re able to fly. What it leads to is a wink-wink games that I and many people perceive as dishonesty, manipulation, and condescension. IMO, this is why the media isn’t trusted; they lie every day. And I don’t mean political bias, they’re lying about being a rarefied elite robot that can’t feel and doesn’t have emotions or opinions.
Partizan media at least allows it’s journalist to come out of the closet and acknowledge that they’re human beings.
For films, milking franchises and IPs because it’s the “safe” investment. That’s why majority of movies coming out are sequels or part of a franchise. Sure there are still original movies out there if you look for them, but you can obviously see what the big studios keep pushing
For news, opinionated delivery. If you call yourself a news channel, there should be 0 opinions on your content. Just deliver the news.
“So-and-so SLAMS such-and-such!”
Then you read the article and So-and-so said such-and-such was being a bit silly.
I also hate news panel shows where panelists are just screaming at each other.
What I consider “mainstream media” in the USA is still the big broadcast companies like ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox etc - plus the big streaming companies like Paramount, Disney etc.
What makes me puke about them is all the garbage propaganda shows about cops, paramilitary cop squads, lawyers, doctors, judges etc. That shit has been stinking up the TV screens of America for decades, and it teaches the population a fantasy version of law enforcement and how public authorities function. And it’s just fucking boring as hell too.
It’s made to be the mouthpiece of the ruling class. Every word they use is tailored to influence our opinion to reflect the thoughts of our billionaire overlords and their political pets.
I crave the familiar, so that usually means old movies. Even if it’s new to me I’m much more likely to watch something from 1920 than 2020. For instance, Nosferatu slaps and it’s fascinating the impact that it’s had and how it ripples out into film and literature today - and when you consider that itself is a ripoff of Dracula you see that even this ancient film is just part of a larger narrative chain.
I’m also a big fan of bad movies, somewhere between B- and Z-list. The 1980s had this explosion of direct-to-video films (the technology finally allowed it) and as filmmaking became accessible to all you start to see a lot more independent voices that aren’t constrained by studio interference. On the flip side, they don’t really have the studio budget either, but the effects can be part of the cheese which is where most of the fun is anyway.
Direct-to-streaming doesn’t have the same magic. It’s hard to pin it down exactly, it might be the preference to use CGI as a crutch as opposed to being constrained by practical effects. But even when it isn’t an effects-driven film I don’t know, there’s something about them. Maybe the cameras are too sharp
In the past, you could shoot your B movie on your own and, as long as you were under budget, nobody cared.
Nowadays, I feel like there’s some asshole studio exec who doesn’t know about movies, but they’re there on the laptops reviewing every shot and giving their asshole opinion.
That it generally is an insult to my intelligence
Too much of it is owned by billionaires who use it to foster their neo liberal agenda.
It’s so forceful that even public media repeats the same narrative only to show they still are in the loop.
Does mainstream media even exist anymore? Everyone’s off in their own silos getting fed exactly what they already believe and want to hear.
I hear people talking about their news sources and I’ve never heard of them anymore but inevitably those sources have millions of followers.
I don’t think I live under a rock; I’ve probably just siphoned myself into my own silos getting fed without even realizing it.
Old people and poor people still watch a lot of broadcast TV (over the air with antenna) and cable TV. Satellite TV is probably going extinct for the most part.
Streaming services are consolidating with several mega-corps homogenizing their content into similar garbage piles.
I often also dislike popular media because of oversaturation. People will keep mentioning it and it just loses all appeal to me, because my brain wants new stimuli.
Similar to how when you say “tomato” a dozen times, it loses its meaning and you rather just make the sound (semantic satiation).I support mainstream media. I believe the public requires access to reliable news, and you simply cannot rely on information from random internet users alone. Someone has to do the work of verifying information. You may not like the format they present the news in, but you would be so much worse off without them.
It is all the same. Media to just consume but not to make you think, to make you realize something. Sit shut up and just consume. Dont think. Consume.
It isnt art but all commerce.


