Existential Comics | Website
Alt Text
“At the heart of Batman’s being, like all theater kids, is a boundless narcissism that eats away at his core.”
Explanation
Many versions of Batman have a strict “no killing” rule, which is exactly the kind of intuition the Trolley Problem is attacking. Why is it different to actively kill someone vs passively letting five people die? In particular, Batman’s version seems to be a sort of “honor code”, which something close to a moral system, but it is entirely inward looking. In other words, fulfilling the honor system doesn’t do good for the world, it elevates the status of the honorable man. In a sense it’s the worst possible way to answer a moral question, “I want to kill the five people because I personally would lose something (my honor)”. Also its pretty showy to dress up as a bat. One might even call him a weirdo.
Transcript
8 Panel Comic
Panel 1: The Riddler stands at the lever explaining his setup of the classic Trolley Problem. Tied to one track are 5 people, and tied to the diverted track is 1 person. A trolley is prepared to mow down the 5 people unless the lever is pulled, diverting it to the path with one person.
Riddler: Alright Batman riddle me this. A trolley is moving down this track and is going to kill five people, but if you switch tracks it will only kill one, do you pull the lever?
Panel 2: Batman shakes his fist at the Riddler
Batman: Curse your implausible games, Riddler!
Panel 3: Batman hesitates in front of the lever, his hand shaking.
Batman: The right thing to do is save five people, but I have sworn to my code of ethics to never kill!
Panel 4: The Riddler exults in the devious dilemma delaying Batman’s decision.
Batman: I cannot do it! I cannot be the one to kill directly!
Riddler: Looks like the Batman has failed Philosophy 101! HAHAHAHAHA!
Panel 5: Batman watches as the trolley splatters 5 people across the track as the Riddler continues in his exultations.
Panel 6: Batman now sits in his Batcave as his Alfred arrives with his dinner on a covered tray.
Alfred: But what I don’t understand Sir, is how upholding your moral code can have more value than their lives?
Panel 7: Batman smoking a cigarette puts on his best grizzled and hard boiled face.
Batman: Because I’m a narcissist, Alfred. I value my own ego above everything, and I didn’t want to lose the “no killing” thing, because I like bragging about it. That’s all.
Panel 8: Alfred is shocked at Batman’s response.
Alfred: Really, I never thought so…
Batman: I dress up as a bat to fight crime. Of course I’m a narcissist. Your kind of a moron, Alfred, honestly.
Maybe killing came more from those who made up the system than the final operator that had to choose. As billionaire, Batman is already the killer
Batman is a billionaire who dresses up in black leather, drives around in a fancy car, and beats the shit out of impoverished purse snatchers. He’s a little more than a narcissist.
It’s his personal therapy time. I used to like the idea when I was a kid but growing up it really showed the flaws.
What if Bruce Wayne had invested all his money to create social services and help people with mental issues, therefor preventing the joker from becoming a psychopath?
it’s not Batman’s fault a serial killer isn’t given the death penalty, or somehow kept in prison.
I’m the comics Batman would have secretly replaced all the bodies with dummies somehow before this happened. but not just gotten Riddler arrested… for reasons.
If an evil person wants to force you to make a choice, make them take full responsibility by not choosing anything.
Since it was forced on you, it’s an artificial decision. If the game is wrong the right thing is to not play.
Now make one where the dems are tying people to the tracks as Israel hands them bags of money. Then you reward the bribe takers. Trolley problem comics are some of the dumbest zionist trash ever.
<entitled> Now make one where <political non sequitur> the dems are tying people to the tracks as Israel hands them bags of money. <evocative language> Then you reward the bribe takers. <lousy take> Trolly problem comics are some of thr dumbest zionist trash ever.
Man I hope this was from a bot and not a human. It’s awful.
I too would not do anything. If 5 people are dead that would be an accident and if 1 would die then that would be murder
Jason Todd was right about Batman and the Joker. For the graveyards that Joker has filled, and his tendency to keep escaping, Joker should just fucking die.
Problem is, Todd didn’t do it. Instead he tried proving a point to Wayne and got his ass kicked.
Todd didn’t do it. Instead he tried proving a point to Wayne and got his ass kicked.
Was that the storyline where the Joker brainwashed him or was that a different Robin?
Depends on the timeline. There is one comic series where Jason does actually kill Joker.
But what most people tend to think of is Under the Red Hood from 2010, where Jason is kidnapped and beaten by the Joker in the beginning before supposedly murdered. He survives in secret, returns as the Red Hood, and at a confrontation with Batman discusses how he’s upset that Joker could kill him and that Bruce refuses to kill the Joker in return.
It’s a common theme though. In another timeline one iteration of Selina leaves Bruce because he was willing to risk their lives to save the Riddler despite how he was entirely responsible for the situation that got himself killed.
You know who does kill Joker in a lot of timelines though? Superman. He usually ends up going a bit authoritarian afterwards but Bruce will even admit in some of those situations that Joker’s death is necessary.
Unironically, Injustice was good until Chapter 5(?) Where Superman and WW show up to forcibly break up a protest against their actions
Up until then they were doing actual good. But of course every story has to go “absolute power corrupts” OT whatever and before you know it
Spoiler
Superman becomes a Yellow Lantern to McGuffin him surviving getting shot with a Kryptonite bullet, and his half of the JLA still support him unconditionally
You know who does kill Joker in a lot of timelines though? Superman. He usually ends up going a bit authoritarian afterwards
I really liked the Injustice arc
Injustice was really solid as long as you focus on the main cast. I do think a lot of people were disappointed with how Damian was handled.
There’s also the Justice Lords, where Batman reluctantly complies with Superman’s regime and where Superman’s preferred method of punishment is lobotomizing villains.
That was Tim Drake, Robin #3.
What did Todd do in the story you mentioned?
Jason Todd got killed by the Joker by way of repeated contact with a crowbar and a close encounter with some explosives.
Ras Al Guhl for some reason decided to revive him in the Lazarus Pit. It didn’t go so well as Jason’s mind was a little broken at first and he ran off.
Some years go by and he eventually learns Joker is still alive, still killing people, and Batman Just keeps throwing him in Arkham.
So, Jason creates a plot to get the attention of both the Joker and Batman by taking up Joker’s old persona; The Red Hood. Joker is going to get very intrigued by someone masquerading as something from his past, and Batman will get involved because he’s Batman.
The end goal was to force Batman in a situation where he’d be forced to kill the Joker. A situation where either Batman kills the Joker, or he does it himself.
Batman of course ends up defending the Joker and saving him from Jason.
Edit: writing this entirely from memory, so there might be some bent details.
Yeah, batman should really get in the habit of doing extrajudicial executions. Bypass this psychopath’s right to due process under the law and just kill him. And why stop at the Joker? Every masked supervillain should just get executed. Hell, why stop at the masks? Their henchmen knew what they signed up for, why not kill them too? Wouldn’t the world be so much nicer if we simply killed everyone who threatened to kill people?
Batman is a detective. That’s his thing. World’s Greatest Detective. He’s not just assuming anyone’s guilt. It’s also entirely possible to be willing to kill some people for very specific reasons and criteria without then deciding it’s OK to just start killing anyone you consider to be a criminal. Also, Batman exists specifically because the justice system in Gotham is broken, the police force is corrupt, and he feels the people need a real protector. An appeal to authority is situationally blind.
Dude, it’s the Joker. You’re completely missing the point. Even Jason Todd in the comics said “Just this guy, just this ONE guy you know will kill 5 to 10 people every time he escapes”.
Even Killer Croc, despite his name, doesn’t have such a kill count.
Literally, why stop at the Joker? Other guys don’t have as high of a kill count, but once The Joker Is dead, one of them is going to be the new kill leader. The exact same argument for killing the Joker also applies to whoever’s in first place after he dies.
I think you are the one who misses the point. You and I know that the Joker will escape from Arkham and kill again, but Batman doesn’t. Even if Gotham PD is extremely corrupt, even if it’s possible for convicts to escape Arkham asylum, Batman has to believe that it is possible for justice to be served, because if he stops believing that then he’ll become the most prolific mass murderer in history.
There is an ocean of difference between your average serial killer and the amount of people Joker has single-handedly killed. Every argument about morality of killing someone just doesn’t work if you’re arguing about the Joker.
And yes, Batman absolutely does know this. But he has personal issues that are so deeply fucked up he’ll literally save Joker from death if someone else tries to do what he can’t.
I will argue Batman is already a mass murderer, by virtue of not killing the Joker.
I love when y’all try to lemmysplain Batman to me, as if you’ve ever read any of the comics or watched any of the shows or movies or know anything about the character outside of these circlejerks on the internet. Next you’re going to tell me that Bruce Wayne could do a lot better for Gotham if he simply opened up free medical clinics and homeless shelters and started jobs programs, right?
Um. Yes. You know Batman the Animated Series?
Also watched Justice League Unlimited. Read some pretty good early 2000s comics. You have no idea who you’re talking to.
Next you’re going to tell me that Bruce Wayne could do a lot better for Gotham if he simply opened up free medical clinics and homeless shelters and started jobs programs, right?
Except Bruce Wayne is actually doing this. The Nolan movies don’t show much of that, and neither the animated movies, but he is actually trying to buy up plots and build shelters, clinics, and schools.
Emphasis on “try”, because the corruption goes so deep in Gotham there is a whole court of rich people with a vested interest in keeping Gotham the way it is.
You would know if you’ve read anything from batman outside of these “circlejerks on the Internet”.
I love when y’all try to lemmysplain Batman to me
Clearly it’s necessary.
Its a legitimate complaint, but we are also talking about an 80+ yr old charector, so there are endless iterations of what could be right and what could be wrong for him to do, since hes done so much to so many.
Also, Gotham has an ancient unfathomable curse, so it can’t ever be “good,” no matter how much money Wanyetech pours into it.
Then again, maybe Superman boy can PUNCH FUCKING REALITY again and make every arguement irrelevant till they wrap around again.
In the trolley problem you need to also know if the trolley has passengers. If not, switch the track while it’s on there to make it derail and save both sides.
Alternatively, maybe a derailment is more survival than getting squashed.so derailling is the best solution. But no sources on that
The extreme of this is Cheng Xin from “Death’s End”.
“I will sacrifice everything that exists to protect the purity of my conscience. Even betray people doing exactly what I told them acting under my explicit instructions.”
That was not what happened at all. Cheng Xin had no ability to actually save anyone, her choice was to kill all the other guys as well, while also further guaranteeing the extinction of humanity. That’s MAD theory, not trolley problem. If anything, humanity fucked up by electing someone who did not project enough menace for MAD theory to work: the whole point of MAD theory is the threat of response, the response itself doesn’t actually matter.
That’s one thing I found very interesting. Luo Ji’s spell was no different from Ray Diaz’s plan with Mercury. Same exact solution, except instead of directly offing humanity by human action, he was simply calling out to the predators he knew would come along and off humanity.
Hot take: the instinct to not pull the lever is the entire basis for modern right-libertarianism.
For those who don’t know: the idea is that active coercion is bad and unjust, while passively allowing social structures to be coercive is not (or at least isn’t relevant to politics). In fact, “unjust” can not be an emergent property of a society - per definition! A society where no individual transactions are coercive, will always be a just society.
The only way I can make sense of that, is to point to that instinct as the only relevant moral intuition.
A moral code is something that you adopt because, in calm reflection and rational analysis, you have determined that it’s the best approach to producing desirable outcomes. The reason for having a code instead of just evaluating things in the moment is because of the recognition that your judgement can be compromised, by being tempted, by being angry, by not having time in the heat of the moment, etc.
Personally, I’d say that every rule has exceptions and that you should be willing to break a rule in extraordinary circumstances. For a recovering alcoholic, “don’t drink” is a good rule to have, but if there’s some convoluted hypothetical with a serial killer holding hostages demanding that you take a shot, then you can make an exception. But that exception does not invalidate the rule, which is generally a good thing to follow. And you should be extremely cautious about whether the exception is actually valid, or whether it’s just your brain inventing excuses.
I don’t think that being too rigid in upholding a code is “narcissistic” or “egotistical.” In fact, it’s often just the opposite. It may be precisely because Batman is aware of his own flaws that he doesn’t trust himself to break the rule, without his judgement becoming compromised.
But by being unwilling to adapt his judgment is already compromised.
How many situations have there been in actual Batman media[1] where Batman refuses to kill someone knowing that doing so will directly cause the imminent deaths of innocent people? Not some theoretical future harm based on an assumption that a criminal will escape and kill again, a situation where subduing a criminal is not enough to prevent them from killing someone and the only way to save a life is by killing the bad guy first.[2]
The argument always seems to be that Batman should kill the Joker instead of capturing him because the Joker will escape again and thus will kill again. Of course, in-universe the Joker’s escape is not inevitable. We only know he will always escape because he is a popular villain that the writers will keep bringing back. Batman can’t know that. And even with that knowledge the argument falls apart because killing Joker won’t stop him anymore than arresting him would.
But beyond that, why is it Batman’s job to play judge, jury and executioner? And exactly how do we decide when someone is so evil and dangerous that they should be killed even if they could instead be captured and imprisoned? The whole argument starts looking a lot shakier when we take away the costumes and start applying the same logic to normal people in the real world. I suspect most of us would be uncomfortable with a cop just shooting someone instead of arresting them because they figured they’d end up back on the street at some point, or a paramedic letting an unconscious murder suspect bleed out because they might kill again.
Also, we already have Batman but he kills people. He’s called the Punisher. Somehow, despite decades of waging a much more literal war on crime, all those innocent people don’t seem to be any safer. Funny how that works.[3]
Excluding the ones that ignore the no killing rule, obviously ↩︎
The closest I can recall is a cartoon where he and several other heroes had the opportunity to kill Granny Goodness, and then later he had the opportunity to blow up Apokolips and take out Darkseid and all of his minions. The former is a somewhat questionable decision because she can’t be arrested and imprisoned, it was a choice between killing her and letting go and the harm she would inflict afterwards is predictable if not immediate. The latter is a more impactful decision, but it’s a lot harder to argue that getting everyone out alive and ending the immediate conflict is obviously morally inferior to killing an entire planet full of people (including yourself, your team and the people you came to rescue) just to take out its leaders. ↩︎
Yes, I know, this is applying meta logic again, but that’s half the point. No course of action the hero takes will ever succeed if doing so would completely undermine the core concept of an ongoing series. And without being able to rely on some out-of-universe justification to claim that the consequences will be better, it’s pretty fucking hard to argue that the Punisher’s methods are morally superior from an in-universe perspective. ↩︎
The real batman would’ve anticipated this and had a plan to save all the people, and arrest the riddler. Psh
This is kind of the reason I don’t like the trolley problem. I understand the reason that it’s presented as a choice of two options, but it feels so contrived and so limiting to have other answers as invalid. Thinking can be so multidimensional and crushing it into a binary limits critical thinking.
He would wait for the spiky things to appear above above the train and hit Y















