seen a bunch of people just hating on the Catholic church and even catholics for no logical reason at all
OK, After reading most of the comments, OP is clearly sealioning. Locking.
Any institution that allows and venerates shitheads like “Mother Teresa” is undeserving of respect.
hey so, mother teresa ran multiple orphanages and distributed food to poor in Calcutta, India.
the missionaries of charity are still currently an active order there, performing charity
“Suffering makes you closer to God”… Except when it’s MY suffering. Then I’m allowed to go to a real hospital and get treatment.
She was a fucking hypocrite and a sadistic person.
???
You really ought to read up on her. She was an awful person.
Mate she was a fucking cunt.
She kept people sick and refused to give them medicine because she felt that prolonging their pain brought them closer to God.
Brother she was forcing sick kids to reuse needles
Well, what’s there not to hate about the biggest paedo ring in the world?
strawman
I don’t think you understand what that means.
You asked for reasons, I gave you one.
how is it a paedo ring?
Damn son, you’re an idiot
when you accuse the church of something, you need proof
Do you want people to show you how to use the internet?
The Pope even apologies for it…
yes, for a few cases at the diocesan level

No reason? Do you not hear about the excessive amount of sexual abuse that the church encourages through there non action or outright moving sexual predators to another area to avoid community problems.
Or their stance on safe sex, which shockingly, is not safe at all.
All to appease their magical invisible friend in the sky.
strawman
Calling these reasons strawman argument tells a lot about you…
Yeah I don’t think you know what that word means.
Quick question: Is everything alright upstairs, brother? Like is everything okay at home?
yes, I just had some success on my garden, with a few flowers :)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informal_fallacy
Read. Learn.
Lol that isn’t like a word of power that you can just throw out there and win an argument. It actually has a meaning, and this ain’t it
“Lemme see why people hate my religion… Oh no, they brought up a reason why they hate my religion! I know the perfect way to counter this argument!”
So you are just a cunt.
.pɐǝɥʞɔᴉp .ʎɐʍ uɐᴉlɐɹʇsn∀ lɐnsn ʎɯ uᴉ ʇɐɥʇ uɐǝɯ ʇ’uop I pu∀
No logical reason at all?
Without going through a host of historical atrocities, modern day misdeeds and crimes, you could simply look at the global systematic and institutionalized protection of raping of little boys…for centuries. This alone would warrant the hate.
Bet you also wonder why the world hates Israel with a fiery passion too.
false equivalence, strawman
Okay. Guess you’re wondering what the big deal is about the Epstein Files?
The Catholic Church makes Epstein and all of the pedos involved look like JV league amateurs.
I’m really not sure what you expected asking this question in your post. The Catholic Church deserves every bit of hate and more than it currently receives.
I was raised Catholic. Fuck the Catholic Church
I wasnt. I discovered the Faith with Gods guidance.
and cite your sources
So you have psychosis
back to the 1800s “accuse them of insanity when they say something you didnt quite like” technique, I see?
It’s just an objective oberservation. No matter if someone tells me they have magical powers, have seen unicorns or believe in god: All of that is stupid and proves something is wrong with you.
God is real, there are a bunch of scientifically proven miracles…
Lmao, you can’t be fucking serious. Not gonna spend any more time here explaining this but will leave this
If you’re actually this naïve, try perusing the references located at the bottom of this page. However, I suspect you will discredit it in some manner. Or try to brush off the 165+ sources describing exactly what everybody else is saying here.
A bit of advice? Just accept the fact that the Catholic Church has been fucking little boys in the ass for centuries. This will make it easier for you moving forward, because this topic is absolutely common knowledge.


Neat
You might be surprised to find out that atheism is probably over-represented here on Lemmy and is probably the dominant “belief” as opposed to traditional religion.
One aspect of this is that you’ll see that religion in general is not exactly well respected among the userbase. You might just want to alter your expectations, because it’s not anti-catholicism as much as it is anti-religion in general.
Source: Am atheist. All religions are fucking stupid and holding humanity back. Sorry not sorry.
Amen brother, oops I mean … whatever.
Because Lemmy is, for the most part, atheist. The reason why Catholicism seems to get more hate than any other religion is because it’s more often mentioned in media posted. And as for your “no reason” claim, you might want to read up on news regarding systemic issues with the catholic church and its hush-culture.
And you might want to read up on what the strawman-falacy is before trying to call everyone out on it. It’s not a strawman argument when people refer to specific issues or examples that answers your original question. Being able to name argumentation techniques and fallacies does not make you right.
“sky daddy” is a strawman, because youre perverting the belief to make it seem crazy
It literally is crazy. What is ’god’ other than the father of everything (daddy) living in the sky?
Also, finally fucking research what a strawman is.
heaven is not “the sky” and the CREATOR and the Eternal Father, not daddy
Cannibalism of zombie wizard. And before you dismiss it away as “strawman”, please carefully explain how transubstantiation during the Eucharist is not:
- magic
- cannibalism
We can use whatever terms you like. But I will draw a hard line at consuming human flesh and calling it anything other than cannibalism. Either it literally happens and that is pretty fucking gross, or it doesn’t in which case the whole point is moot and crazy to think it does happen.
we are eating the body of Christ and drinking the blood of Christ. Not in the cannibalism way tho, and “magic”, say, is anything supernatural right? God cannot be comprehended by us, and nothing happens that is supernatural, but just out of our understanding of nature.
and Jesus wasnt a wizard. He was and is the son of God
Jesus Christ proclaimed at the last supper “this is my body, eat” because the crucifixion was nigh, and he was literally sacrificing himself for our sins so we may reap what we did not sow
Not in the cannibalism way tho
Nonsense response. What is the definition of cannibalism? Here, let me provide a link: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cannibalism
You have not explained why eating the flesh and blood of another human is not cannibalism.
God cannot be comprehended by us, and nothing happens that is supernatural, but just out of our understanding of nature.
So does the transubstantiation happen? Does that little cracker turn into some Jesus liver pate? Does that thimble sip of wine turn into O-neg blood? According to catholic.com (a reputable source, right?), it literally happens.
and Jesus wasnt a wizard. He was and is the son of God
He wasn’t a wizard? Someone who exercises supernatural powers? You know who else was the son of a god? Hercules. He wasn’t really a wizard tho, so plus one to Jesus, I guess.
he was literally sacrificing himself for our sins so we may reap what we did not sow
For an immortal godbeing to be inconvenienced for a weekend doesn’t seem like much of a sacrifice. Let’s assume it actually happened. The whole torture, crown of thorns, spikes in the hands/feet (nevermind that wouldn’t actually pin a human to an actual crucifix), it was what? A day or two all together? If this was nearly 2000 years ago, that’s like 730,000 days ago. So let’s say five days total: 2 of the dying, 3 of being dead in a tomb (long weekend). Five days out of 730,000. Is it really a sacrifice?
No, that is not an example of a strawman argument
it is, because its making a strawman out of the beliefs and arguments of the church to make it easier to attack
Look, I will quote wikipedia for you:
straw man fallacy (sometimes written as strawman) is the informal fallacy of refuting an argument different from the one actually under discussion, while not recognizing or acknowledging the distinction.[1] One who engages in this fallacy is said to be “attacking a straw man”.
Calling somebodies god a sky daddy or invisible sky friend is not a fundamentally different thing than calling it god. It is disrespectful, but not a strawman. Nobody is questioning your belief in your god, they are just mocking it.
To give you an example of what actual strawman fallacy looks like, here is one from wikipedia again:
Another example of a strawman argument is U.S. president Richard Nixon’s 1952 “Checkers speech”.[13][14] When campaigning for vice president in 1952, Nixon was accused of having appropriated $18,000 in campaign funds for his personal use. In a televised response, based on Franklin D. Roosevelt’s Fala speech, he spoke about another gift, a dog he had been given by a supporter:[13][14]
It was a little cocker spaniel dog, in a crate he had sent all the way from Texas, black and white, spotted, and our little girl Tricia, six years old, named it Checkers. And, you know, the kids, like all kids, loved the dog, and I just want to say this right now, that, regardless of what they say about it, we are going to keep it.
This was a straw man response; his critics had never criticized the dog as a gift or suggested he return it. This argument was successful at distracting a number of people from the funds and portraying his critics as nitpicking and heartless. Nixon received an outpouring of public support and remained on the ticket. He and Eisenhower were later elected.
No it doesn’t
👁️👁️
🫎
It’s a metaphor. The Abrahamic god is not technically in the sky, but he has been called the almighty father and heaven has been represented to be in the clouds enough times even if technically isn’t that everyone understands what “Sky daddy” means. It’s a derogatory term, sure, that’s the point. The term being derogatory doesn’t make it a strawman though.
It’s an insult and the Abrahamic god isn’t a protected individual so whatever.
Actually, supposing that God exists somewhere above us in the clouds physically makes much more sense than God living literally everywhere at once, while also living outside of our universe, and also living as a physical person 2,000 years ago, and also living in the past, and the future all at once.
“Sky daddy” is extremely charitable all things considered.
omnipotence, please research it
Lol. I know what it means, I’m suggesting its more insane than a sky daddy.
Well, Duh, hes God. Hes not restrained to space and time
That’s what makes it more insane, not less.
I haven’t seen any hate specifically towards the Catholic Church (I was raised Catholic, I think I’d notice). Lemmy is majority atheist and we live in countries whose cultures are at the very least heavily influenced by religions so there’s no love for theists.
What you MAY be seeing is people reacting to the rampant child abuse done by Catholic clergy that is regularly reported on and never really addressed.
I’d say no culture got not influenced by faith. Faith and culture went hand in hand for a very long time. Culture formed religion and religion formed culture
True, that’s what I said, no?
I think they just meant that it is true for all countries, since every culture in earth is affected that way. So the distinction “people here come from countries,…” is redundant.
Fair. I wanted to point out that we all experience some influence of religion(s) in our daily lives and thus have opinions. I suppose I could’ve worded that less ambiguous.
I can’t speak for all of Lemmy, but I am against the Catholic Church for a number of reasons. They hid child abuse for decades (centuries?) by shuffling around the offenders, essentially protecting them from any consequences. They accept donations with the explicit stated reason to perform charitable acts, but the percentage they actually spend on charity is so small it would be illegal in a lot of places if an actual non-profit did it. They hold back science. Though it’s not a requirement, many practice circumcision, which is essentially mutilating a child. I could probably keep going, but that’s enough.
they do not hold back science at all they do MULTIPLE charities in foreign countries, I have seen them with my very own eyes
and the shuffling around is at a diocesan level in the US, not the vatican
I didn’t say they don’t do charity, I said the percentage of their donations they actually spend on charity would be criminal for a non-profit.
The child abuse and coverup problem is absolutely not limited to the US:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_cases
Whether one thinks the church holds back science is mostly a matter of opinion. It seemed like you were asking for opinions, so I offered mine. If you were looking to debate, I’d maybe reword your original post so you don’t come across as sea lioning. The relationship between the church and science is complex, and to me, the bad outweighs the good.
well, depends on what you count as “charity”. They need to pay for the food of the charity workers, their housing, etc and actual charity, which is usually not logged or kept track of that much, no one notes down a starving childs name before giving him bread to eat
Ooooh… multiple charities… how generous!!!
The catholic church is only estimated to be worth $2.5 trillion (and they have their own country).
To put that in perspective, that’s enough money to spend $1 every second for ~79000 years.
source? and it gives out a BUNCH of money
Here’s an Irish Mayor recounting how Catholic priests raped and beat him repeatedly as a child, and how the catholic church of Rome sent out a priest during the investigation into the rapes just in an effort to discredit him and call him a liar.
can you give me the timestamp when he says the catholic church sent a priest to silence him?
At this point, I am 100% positive you are sea lioning. Just to let you know, you’re not very good at it.
It’s a short video, and I found his speech pretty moving, I’d recommend watching it in its entirety.
I am switching to an upvote because this is excellent engagement with lots of people chiming in about why Catholicism sucks festering donkey dick.
True, but OP is a moron who doesn’t know the definition of “strawman” and dismisses every legitimate criticism of the catholic church as such, so there’s actually very little point to the discussion.
Mandatory George Carlin link:
“but he loves you” sends me every time xD
I personally have nothing against belief sets and organizations that are factually and morally correct. I would much rather simply be a good person instead of abiding by the arbitrary merits of any belief system contingent on a supernatural entity. Belief in absurdities increases proclivity to commit atrocities.
Okay, so we’ll break it down in incresingly narrow boxes :
1- Hatred of religion in general
Religion has been and continues to be a tool for legitimizing power structures. As such, they’re associated with the oppressive systems they’ve historically upheld. That goes from state structures like monarchy to modes of production like slavery, reaching whithin family dynamics, like patriarchy. Atheism was until recently broadly criminalized throughout the world. Atheism, or at least secularism, is a feature of many ideologies that arose since the late 18th century to uproot these systems, while religions are claimed by ideologies that arose in reaction tooto these. Politically, religion is therefore seen as conservative .
2- Hatred of Abrahamic religions
Some see these religions (Christianity, Islam, Druzism, Judaism) as inherently more oppressive than other, because they see it as a sin to worship gods other than their, and do not permit synchretism like other religions do. This is a big debate, and it doesn’t hold true to the same extent for all Abrahamic religions, but I’m not getting into details on this.
3- Hatred of Christianity
There are religious people who hate christianity for theological reasons, but I’m once again more interested in the political aspect. Many hate christianity for its role in colonization and association with western imperialism. It’s basically the first two points applied to specific circumstances of christianity : How it came to eradicate paganism in Europe and attempted (sometimes continues to attempt) to do the same globally, how, using colonial means it erases cultures. Same can be said of Islam to an extent, and you could say the main difference is that Christianity has been successful more recently and more globally. But then again, while they’ve had the same attitude towards paganism, Islam has historically tolerated more religious in their states, as long as these were “religions of the book”. Tho it’s true that the situation has come to be a bit reversed on that point…
4 a- Hatred of Catholicism for theological reasons :
Idk about the details, but part of a reason why the reform happens was that catholicism was seen as drifting to far from true belief and focusing on preserving and enriching itself as an institution. Other accusations include being too close to paganism due to the cult of saints and the continuity with Roman institutions (diocieses that predate the christianisation of the empire, nuns too similar to Vestal virgins…), and the fact that at the time, the mass was always in Latin although most people didn’t understand it.
4 b- Hatred of Catholicism : Post-colonial reasons
Point 3 applied to former colonies of France, Spain and Portugal, for which evangelisation was purely Catholic. the Catholic church continues to wield large power there, and some people consider its influence a remnant of colonialism. However, it is interesting to note that catholicism can be seen the opposite way by people from catholic countries for which a protestantprotestant country is seen as a greater or more recent oppressor (like Ireland or Puerto-Rico).
4 c- Hatred of Catholicism : Structural reasons
Catholiscism has a strict clergy hierarchy, moreso than Protestantism or Islam. Some see this as wrong in itself for philosophical or theological reasons, but even if that is not the case, this means the Catholic Church, more than others, can be perceived as an institution with agency and responsabilities. More than others, they’re expected to answer to their past positions and to solve their ongoing issues, something it struggles with as it doesn’t want to alienate the more concervative parts of its clergy. Also, this leads me to the next point :
4- d : The pedophilia thing. This is already very debated in the other comments, so I’m not gonna get in the details, but clearly not a good look.
4- e: Catholics in majority protestant country
Ecumenical debates pass over the heads of most christians, who just go with the form of christianity that is the “default” in their country/region. But what about those raised in families that hold on to their religions where it is a minority? This point seems important to me because a lot of the debates about Catholiscism I see online are really about catholicism in the USA, where it is a minority. In such countries, catholics will usually be seen as more pious and conservative than other christians, and quite often they’ll be, for several reasons :
-
Principle of selection: A family that is just vaguely christian, upon immigrating, could’ve converted to better integrate. If they didn’t, it’s either because their specific belief was important to them personally, or because the community in which they integrated was mostly of other catholics, making it a solidarity factor which in turn increases its importance.
-
Sense of responsability : If holding a belief is an active choice rather than going with the flow, believers will tend to give it more mind. They may feel they have more of a personal responsability to uphold it. This can culminate in what’s known as “siege mentality”: People who feel like an important part of their way of life or their belief system is threatened will react with fervor, oftem violence. This is why so many religious or political speech relies on tropes such as “They’re trying to steal/destroy/corrupt our thing!”
-
First and foremost all the raping of children. It isn’t just a few bad apples it is an accepted and protected practice by the institution.
Secondly the history of running concentration camps really sours my opinion.
Than there is the about 100 years of slave labor camps that they ran in the UK.
To me it is a mystery why anyone would support this fucked up institution.

the raping of children has been condemned by the church. certain coverups are at the diocesan level not the vatican level
It is comical to me that you think the diocesan organizational level is not part of church.
it is, but you should not hate the entire church because of it, especially when actions have been taken against the perpetrators
Its comical to me that you think it has ended…
They literally elected a fucking Nazi Pope to help with the coverup and he tried to sabotage the pope after him.
Learn to read things you don’t agree with and fact check it, and learn to change your mind when you discover what you thought was wrong.
You need to do this, even by your own religion.
Unquestioning belief is not faith. It is fanaticism.
I bet you think that Trump condemning Epstein MUST mean Trump never committed sexual assault, right?
the pope actually meant it, and Trump isnt the pope.
I’m sure the trump lovers are saying the same thing about the pope who kept all the pedos who got relocated hidden from the law, while keeping them on the payroll.
I want to preface this by saying I’m not here to shit on Catholicism and it’s believers. As with many cases, my problem is with people in power.
While it is true that the Vatican has never been directly involved, the same can be said about the US government and we’re currently seeing that the policy isn’t as rigid as advertised. The stain on the Vatican is due to inaction. There are enough cases of this happening that the public has associated it with the religion as a whole. One would think that the leader of any organization that finds out one of its members is exploiting their role to abuse someone would have that person stripped of their rank and turned over to the authorities along with anyone that aided the bad actor. Were Dominos to find out a branch of their restaurants were using their pizza deliveries as a means of distributing drugs, they would close the business, fire everyone involved, and turn over any existing evidence to the police.
Even if the Vatican genuinely didn’t know about the scandal until it made the news, it still didn’t do anything about it until long after the public image was damaged. You would think the voice of God on earth would channel some of that divine wrath at the person who broke their oath to the church, broke their oath to their flock, broke the law of the land, had sex out of wedlock, had homosexual sex, harmed a child, and did it all in one go and occasionally multiple times over the course of decades. That’s 6 different things that the church has taken a strong stance to condemn. Were it you or me they would be quick to call us devils. Instead we can sum up the response in a jpeg and it sounds about as wrathful as a zoning board meeting.
That in turn brings me to the real issue here, of isn’t the church that people are angry at, that’s just where the anger goes when they don’t have the scope to see the real problem. The problem lies in tribalism and inaction in places of power. The Vatican didn’t cut off the tainted limb because it was one of theirs, that means it can’t be bad. When a police officer murders a minority or beats his wife, the rest don’t bat an eye because a member of their tribe couldn’t possibly be a bad guy. The reason politicians won’t close ranks and publishing the Epstein class is because that would mean admitting their peers are bad. To admit fault in the tribe is to weaken the tribe and a weak tribe cannot remain powerful. Instead they blame the victims and hide the truth until the entire body dies of sepsis then have the gull to ask why no one wants them to survive.
concentration camps?
Look up Jastrebarsko children’s camp.
Bad faith.
i dont just mean the church but your style of posting here.


















